Rethinking Decision-Making: What can be automated with AI?

Rethinking Decision-Making: What Can Be Automated?

Decision-making is evolving rapidly in today’s volatile and complex business landscape. Organizations are turning to AI and automation to enhance speed, accuracy, and efficiency. But while automation has transformed many aspects of business operations, it raises a crucial question: Where should automation stop, and where must human judgment remain? 

Automation can optimize processes, analyze vast datasets, and even predict future trends. However, not all decisions can be reduced to an algorithm. The growing investment in AI for frontline employee replacement, such as automated customer service agents, highlights the importance of balancing technological advancements with human interaction to preserve trust and value creation. 

The critical question is not simply about what can be automated but rather why automation is being pursued. Are we using AI to enhance decision-making, or merely to accelerate processes? The intention behind automation matters—without a clear purpose, organizations risk implementing optimization without critical thinking. AI should be a means to an end, not an end in itself. 

The rise of automated decision-making:

AI powered decision-making

AI, robotic process automation (RPA), and machine learning have redefined industries by improving efficiency and reducing human error. From financial modeling to customer service chatbots, organizations are leveraging automation to streamline operations and enhance decision-making. 

When Industry 4.0 was introduced in 2010, it marked the beginning of the fourth industrial revolution for the retail industry. Industry 4.0 technologies, including AI, were incorporated into the retail sector, giving rise to the concept of Retail 4.0. 

In Retail 4.0, the use of AI in marketing enables better organization of practitioners’ tasks, enhancing productivity by minimizing unnecessary actions and reducing stress from workload. It also allows for anytime, anywhere collaboration, facilitating idea exchange, problem-solving, and innovation related to customer experience (CE). This empowers e-retailers to assess profitability, sales, market value, return on investment, and overall performance within the scope of AI-driven productivity. As noted by Venturini (2022), the changes brought about by new technologies have a transformative impact on productivity. 

However, as AI systems become more autonomous, their impact on business relationships must be carefully managed to avoid unintended consequences, such as power imbalances, ethical concerns, and a deterioration of trust between stakeholders. Some studies suggest that AI’s increasing autonomy can result in suboptimal outcomes if deployed without proper governance, particularly when frontline employees rely on biased data or when automation disrupts existing relationship structures within organizations. This is one reason why ‘explainable AI’ (Rai 2020) has become popular; the ability to transform opaque AI systems into more understandable ones aims to offer transparency and explanations for the behavior of AI algorithms. These explanations are intended to help users incorporate AI recommendations into their decision-making, foster trust, and enhance accountability. 

"Some processes- especially those requiring empathy, ethical reasoning, or strategic vision- resist full automation because they depend on human interpretation and judgement."

Sources: Skedler

What can be automated?

Certain tasks follow structured, predictable patterns, making them ideal for automation. AI-driven processes can efficiently manage payroll processing, regulatory compliance, invoice handling, and procurement. In domains like marketing, finance, and cybersecurity, AI can analyze massive datasets to optimize campaigns, detect fraud, and predict risk. In operations, predictive maintenance, logistics optimization, and workforce scheduling enhance efficiency without significant trade-offs. 

However, even in these areas, full automation without human intervention can have unintended negative effects. Automated decision-making can create power asymmetries, remove necessary human oversight, and, in some cases, lead to the destruction of value rather than its creation . A critical balance must be maintained to ensure AI functions as a tool rather than a substitute for judgment. 

Where human judgement remains essential:

AI can assist in decision-making, but it cannot replace creativity, vision, and long-term strategic thinking. Leaders must interpret AI-driven insights within the broader context of their organization’s mission and market dynamics. Ethical dilemmas—such as bias in AI models or the societal impact of automation—require human oversight. Research suggests that AI autonomy can sometimes lead to unintended consequences, including decision-making based on flawed or biased data, which can perpetuate inequalities or damage trust (Castillo et al., 2021). Businesses must establish guidelines to ensure AI-driven decisions align with regulatory and ethical standards. 

Another crucial aspect is the impact of AI on relationships within an organization. Empathy, trust, and negotiation are inherently human skills that AI cannot replicate. Whether in sales, leadership, or customer relations, human interaction remains indispensable for building and maintaining strong relationships. Studies highlight that over-reliance on automation in customer service and business relationships can erode trust, reduce innovation potential, and lead to undesirable behaviors within organizations. Maintaining a balance between AI automation and human involvement is critical for sustaining positive relationships among employees and with customers.

Rather than replacing human decision-makers, AI should serve as an augmentation tool—enhancing capabilities, reducing cognitive overload, and providing data-driven recommendations. Emerging trends include hyper-personalization, self-learning systems, and explainable AI (XAI), which aims to address power asymmetries by making AI decision-making processes more transparent and interpretable. The rise of AI-powered decision-support tools highlights the importance of intentionality—organizations must avoid blind optimization and instead ensure AI aligns with broader business objectives and ethical considerations. 

As AI reshapes organizational structures, companies must also consider how it impacts relationships among employees, customers, and other key stakeholders. The most successful businesses will not be those that automate the fastest but those that automate with purpose, strategy, and a deep understanding of their organizational values. 

At Descartes & Mauss, the focus is on equipping organizations with the right AI tools to enhance decision-making without compromising human judgment. By leveraging advanced AI-driven platforms, D&M helps businesses integrate AI across various functions, empowering leaders with actionable insights that align with their strategic goals. 

We believe that AI should augment human capabilities, not replace them. Whether it’s through automating routine tasks or offering predictive insights, D&M enables clients to streamline operations while ensuring that key decisions remain under human oversight. This approach ensures that AI supports rather than overrides creativity, ethical considerations, and long-term vision. 

Conclusion: Striking the Right Balance

AI and automation are powerful tools, but they should not dictate decision-making without human oversight. Leaders must establish guardrails to ensure AI aligns with business values and strategic goals. Companies should adopt a hybrid decision-making model, where AI handles routine tasks while humans oversee complex, strategic, and ethical considerations. Additionally, organizations should develop clear policies to mitigate potential negative effects of AI-driven automation, particularly regarding trust and relationship dynamics within B2B interactions. 

Ultimately, not everything is automatable. There is no universally “best” decision—choices depend on context, values, and risk tolerance. Automation should serve as an enabler, not a substitute, for critical thinking and human insight. Organizations must ask themselves: Are we using AI to make better decisions, or are we simply optimizing without questioning the impact? The answer will define the future of business strategy in the age of AI. 

Scroll to Top